Compare Food Dehydrators: Nesco or Excalibur?
 Excalibur Food Dehydrator (Photo Credits: Excalibur)
Food dehydrators are used to remove water content from foods in order to eliminate the humid environment required by bacteria to develop. This makes it possible keeping the dried foods for extended periods.
Most Electric food dehydrators make use of heating elements, fans and air vents to generate the hot air flow required for the dehydration. The foods to be dehydrated are placed on stacked food trays. When buying a dehydrator, it is better to get one with the fan and the heating elements at the top or on the side of the unit, rather than at the bottom. This is because, when they are at the bottom, they tend to get soiled by liquids dripping from the foods contained in the trays. This makes the unit hard to clean and decreases its durability. Also, if you cannot wait around for the drying process to complete, you should consider getting a unit with a timer and automatic shut-off feature. It is definitely worth paying the extra few dollars to obtain a dehydrator that will allow you to set and forget! When you compare food dehydrators in the Amazon Best Seller List, at the time this review was written, out of the first 50 best selling dehydrators, 11 belonged to Nesco and 13 belonged to Excalibur! No other brand comes even close to this sort of popularity. Nesco and Excalibur must be doing something right! But which will respond better to your needs: Nesco or Excalibur? Nesco makes round and expandable dehydrators, while Excalibur focuses on rectangular and fixed size units. Round dehydrators usually have top or bottom mounted heaters and fans, while rectangular units usually have side mounted heaters and fans (on the back of the unit). So, with round units, when the heater is at the top, you have top-to-bottom air flow, and the bottom trays may not dry at the same rate as the top ones, and if the heater is at the bottom, you have bottom-to-top air flow, and the top trays may not dry at the same rate as the bottom ones. To get all trays dry at the same rate, rotation of tray positions may be required. This is not required with rectangular dehydrators since the heated air flow emanates from the backside of the unit and applied horizontally and uniformly to all the stacked trays. The two electric food dehydrators carefully chosen here for review are the Nesco FD-1010 & FD-61 and the Excalibur 3926TB & 3900B. These products are some of the best you can buy nowadays in their product category, and have enjoyed great reviews from both Amazon customers and many respected reviewers.
|
|
Nesco FD-1010 and FD-61 Food Dehydrators:
Nesco FD-1010 Food Dehydrator
Even though it has a bottom mounted fan system, it uses a patented special air flow technology that forces heated air first up the exterior pressurized chamber and then horizontally across each individual tray. Therefore, according to product specifications, there is no need to rotate trays like in most dehydrators with bottom or top mounted fan systems. Air pressure adjusts automatically to number of trays used. For a 2400 RPM motor this dehydrator is surprisingly quiet. Because different foods require different drying temperatures, it is equipped with an adjustable thermostat that can be set from 95F to 155F. The housing has an opaque exterior which blocks light and retains thus more nutrients during drying.
It comes with the following accessories included:
- One no-spill solid sheet for drying semi-liquids such as soups, sauces, or fruit rolls.
- One mesh sheet that allows easy drying of small items.
- One jerky spice packet and cure.
- A 52-page recipe and instruction book
Nesco FD-61 Food Dehydrator
Note that, if you need to dry large quantities of foods, the FD-1010, which can expand up to 30 trays, is a better choice than the FD-61. If you do get the FD-1010, one easy way to avoid any drips into the bottom mounted fan system is placing a solid tray at the very bottom of the tray rack. Any drips will then be collected by the bottom tray.
Excalibur 3926TB and 3900B Food Dehydrators:
It is equipped with an adjustable thermostat which allows to set temperatures from a low 95F to a high 155F. The provided temperature range is low enough to preserve health-wise beneficial active enzymes in veggies and fruits, but also high enough to meet safety requirements for drying meat for jerky.
But the best part of this unit is its timer that can be set up to 26 hours. This is a true set-and-forget type unit. It automatically turns off when the set time is complete. A Guide to Dehydration booklet is included. It comes both in black and in white, and a limited 10-year warranty.
The Excalibur product line also offers the Excalibur 3900B 9-tray model which is identical to the Excalibur 3926TB, minus the timer. So, if you think that you don't need a timer, you could buy the 3900B model and save about $50.
So which Food Dehydrator to buy?
So, when you compare food dehydrators, if you are still wondering whether to buy Nesco or Excalibur, consider well the following points:
1If you need to dry very large quantities of foods get the Nesco FD-1010 which can expand up to 30 trays.
2If you want a unit with a back (or side) mounted fan system, then get an Excalibur. Even though the patented special air flow design of the Nesco units are supposed to avoid tray rotation, some Amazon Nesco customers have noted that they did have to resort to rotation to achieve better results.
3If you don't want a unit with a bottom mounted fan system to prevent any possibility of liquids dripping into the heating chamber and fan, then you should get either the Nesco FD-61 or any Excalibur.
4Finally, if you want a unit with a timer and automatic shut-off, then you should get the Excalibur 3926TB, since the Nesco units do not come with any timers.
Note that there are dozens of food dehydrators out there that you can get for a lot less than those reviewed here. But by saving a few dollars you will lose a lot in quality, features, durability, and in the results you will obtain. The Nesco and Excalibur units reviewed may cost a bit more, but should normally provide you with total satisfaction.
Selected Nesco and Excalibur Food Dehydrators on Amazon
Nesco Food Dehydrators:
Note that if some prices are not shown on the Amazon link images below, they will be provided once you click the images.
Nesco FD-1010 and the FD-61
Food Dehydrators
Excalibur Food Dehydrators:
Excalibur 3926TB and 3900B
Food Dehydrators
Have you not found yet what you were looking for?
Global Amazon Search
If you have not found what you are looking for among the above offerings, you can still search for it or for ANY OTHER PRODUCT you may need by clicking below and searching for what you need on Amazon.com:
