Author: Maurice Savaryego, M.Sc.Eng. (Learn More)
|
|
The article will compare the following 50-inch electric linear fireplaces which were the most popular among Amazon customers at the time this article was written (these fireplaces had also received excellent reviews with an average rating of at least 4 stars each, out of 5 stars):
If you are in a hurry, and you would like to see right away price information on the above listed fireplaces, please click below:
Linear Electric Fireplaces on Amazon
Comparing the Selected Linear Electric Wall Mounted Fireplaces
The following pictures show the Touchstone and Napoleon fireplaces to be compared:
|
|
|
The following table compares the various features that come with these fireplaces.
Please read the explanations to the table notes that follow for a better understanding of the features.
Table Notes 1 - 8 Explained:
Note 1:
Note 2:
Note 3:
Both fireplaces considered here come with a remote-control device that allows invocation of all controls that can be invoked from the control panel on the units.
Note 4:
Note 5:
The no-heat setting of both fireplaces considered here operates the unit without heat, for flame effect only.
Note 6:
Napoleon Allure allows changing the color of the flame: either orange, blue or both colors.
Note 7:
Note 8:
For exact price information on the Touchstone and Napoleon fireplaces considered here, please refer to the Amazon products section below. Note that sometimes Amazon provides a discount on the List Price of sold products. If a discount exists, both the List Price and the actual Amazon Price will be shown when you click the Amazon product link images below.
Note 1:
- Touchstone Onyx has its control panel on the side of the unit. Therefore, if the unit is recessed into the wall, it can not be accessed. In that case only the remote-control can be used.
- Napoleon Allure has a touch display panel in front of the unit. Note that the on-screen controls dim after 10 seconds, disappearing completely off screen.
Note 2:
- Touchstone Onyx was designed to be mounted on the wall like flat-panel TV. Because it has the heat vent on top of the unit, it should not be recessed into the wall unless you are planning to use the unit with the heat turned off. But, even then, because the control buttons are on the side of the unit, you will not be able to access them if the unit is recessed into the wall. The preferred way of mounting this unit is on the surface of the wall like a TV, and not recessed into the wall.
- Napoleon Allure has its control panel and heating element in front of the unit. It can be mounted on the surface of the wall like a TV, or it can be recessed into the wall for a flush mount.
Note 3:
Both fireplaces considered here come with a remote-control device that allows invocation of all controls that can be invoked from the control panel on the units.
Note 4:
- TheTouchstone fireplace can be set to high heat, low heat or no heat: When the heat control button is pressed, the fan blows cool air for 10 seconds, and then starts blowing warm air as it is in the low heat mode (750W). When the button is pressed for a second time, the unit starts blowing hot air and goes into the high heat mode (1500W). Finally, if the button is pressed again, the heater turn off, the fan blows cool air and then turns off.
Note that there is no Thermostat and no temperature selection. - Napoleon Allure is thermostat controlled and the desired temperature level can be set either on the touch control panel or using the remote-control device. The unit allows you select the following operation modes:
- No heater or blower.
- Blower only.
- Heater blows warm air (750W).
- Heater blows hot air (1500W).
Note 5:
The no-heat setting of both fireplaces considered here operates the unit without heat, for flame effect only.
Note 6:
Napoleon Allure allows changing the color of the flame: either orange, blue or both colors.
Note 7:
- The Touchstone fireplace allows you to adjust the flames depending on your desired luminosity with five flame brightness settings, which ranges from a dull ember glow to a full blazing light.
- Napoleon Allure allows controlling the intensity of both the blue and orange flames. You could have the orange flame at zero and the blue flame at maximum intensity, or vice versa, the blue flame at zero and the orange flame at maximum intensity. Or you could have a combination of both flame types with any desired intensity.
Note 8:
- The Touchstone fireplace is equipped with a timer that allows shut off in 30 minutes to 7.5 hours.
- Napoleon Allure is also equipped with a timer. It has 9 Settings: (0.5h, 1h, 2h, 3h, 4h, 5h, 6h, 7h, 8h).
For exact price information on the Touchstone and Napoleon fireplaces considered here, please refer to the Amazon products section below. Note that sometimes Amazon provides a discount on the List Price of sold products. If a discount exists, both the List Price and the actual Amazon Price will be shown when you click the Amazon product link images below.
Napoleon Allure Fireplace (Photo Credits: Napoleon)
So which of the electric fireplaces is best for you?
The linear electric fireplaces considered here are excellent products as shown by the good reviews and excellent average rating each had received from Amazon customers at the time this article was written. Indeed, they had each received an average rating of 4.5 stars (out of 5 stars)! Therefore, there is a good chance that you would be quite happy with any of these fireplaces.
However, there are some important differences that you may want to consider before making up your mind:
Clearly, Napoleon Allure is more expensive than the Touchstone Onyx. But, the additional features, such as the thermostat, the ability to use it in both recessed and surface mount modes without having to turn off the heating, the touch display panel in front of the unit, and the variable ember colors justify the higher price.
However, there are some important differences that you may want to consider before making up your mind:
- If you need a wall mounted or wall recessed electric fireplace for just displaying the beauty of the flames and not for heating the room, then any of these fireplaces can be selected. Note that they all have a no-heat option.
- If you need the fireplace also for heating the room, then you need to make your selection based on how you will be mounting the fireplace on the wall:
- If you want the fireplace to be recessed into the wall, you should consider the Napoleon Allure. This fireplace has its control panel and the heat element in front of the unit. So, it can safely be recessed into the wall.
- Touchstone Onyx should be recessed into the wall only if the no-heat option will be used, as it has its heating element on top of the unit (not in front!). Note also that when Touchstone Onyx is recessed, you will not be able to access the control panel which is on the side of the unit, and you will need to use the remote-control device to control the fireplace.
- If you need the fireplace to be mounted on the surface of the wall, you can use anyone of these fireplaces listed above, whether you choose to use the unit for heating or not. - Only Napoleon Allure is equipped with a thermostat and allows you to set a desired temperature. Touchstone Onyx has only high heat, low heat and no-heat options.
- Only Napoleon Allure allows modifying the color of the flames: orange, blue or both colors.
- Napoleon Allure comes only with crystal ember, while the Touchstone fireplace comes with both logs and crystals so you can choose the ember type depending on the mood you want to create.
Clearly, Napoleon Allure is more expensive than the Touchstone Onyx. But, the additional features, such as the thermostat, the ability to use it in both recessed and surface mount modes without having to turn off the heating, the touch display panel in front of the unit, and the variable ember colors justify the higher price.
Selected Linear Electric Fireplaces on Amazon
Please click the fireplace of your choice below for price information or to purchase.
Note:
Note:
- When you get the Touchstone Onyx fireplace shown below, both faux-logs and crystals are included in the purchase, so you can use the type of ember you prefer.
- Napoleon Allure comes with a crystal ember.
Touchstone Onyx
|
Napoleon Allure
|
Please Note:
As mentioned above, Touchstone Onyx can not be recessed mounted into the wall and needs to be mounted on the wall like a TV.
If you'd like a Touchstone fireplace that can be recessed mounted into the wall, you might want to consider the Touchstone Sideline 80004 fireplace described below:
As mentioned above, Touchstone Onyx can not be recessed mounted into the wall and needs to be mounted on the wall like a TV.
If you'd like a Touchstone fireplace that can be recessed mounted into the wall, you might want to consider the Touchstone Sideline 80004 fireplace described below:
|
|
|
Note: If you are looking for a wall mounted electric fireplace of different size and different model than those described and compared above, you can view below all Touchstone and Napoleon wall mounted electric fireplaces available on Amazon:
If you have not found the Touchstone wall mounted electric fireplace you need among the above offerings, you can view all Touchstone wall mounted electric fireplaces available on Amazon by clicking below:
ALL TOUCHSTONE WALL MOUNTED ELECTRIC FIREPLACES ON AMAZON
If you have not found the Napoleon wall mounted electric fireplace you need among the above offerings, you can view all Napoleon wall mounted electric fireplaces available on Amazon by clicking below:
ALL NAPOLEON WALL MOUNTED ELECTRIC FIREPLACES ON AMAZON
Have you not found yet what you were looking for?
Global Amazon Search
If you have not found what you are looking for among the above offerings, you can still search for it or for ANY OTHER PRODUCT you may need by clicking below and searching for what you need on Amazon.com:
